ultimatum77 wrote:I'd take Brady, Brees, Wilson, Mahomes and Newton (although he's out injured) any of these over Rodgers any day. I never said Rodgers wasn't a top 10 qb, you are just so in love with Rodgers that you did not read my post correctly and just putting words in my mouth lol....re-read it and you will see I no longer consider him top 5/elite due to his playoff record and regression since 2016.
I asked you to define what your idea of elite is.
Mahomes is clearly the top dog right now. Wilson is on a great run. I think Rodgers is as good as anyone else, maybe Watson being an exclusion.
Newton.. yeah, okay. Speaking of past their prime former MVPs who haven't been to the Super Bowl recently..
ultimatum77 wrote:I'm not on that Rodgers hype train that's been rolling ever since he won 1 superbowl....where everybody just says oh my gosh Aaron Rodgers.....and yet he only has 1 superbowl.....until he wins another one he's just overrated by the media/fans. Plenty of NFL analysts agree that he is overrated at this point in his career. Still a good qb, but living on fan legacy at this point in terms of rating.
Your knock on him and the 1 Super Bowl, which is really a knock on the Packers.
No QB in this League would have won a Super Bowl with the 2011-2018 Packers. Not a single one.
Rodgers is not living off his past rep.
Rodgers 2019 rating - 103.7
Rodgers career rating - 103.2 (highest of all-time)